Internet Store and Ecommerce Solution Provider - Free Web Site - Free Web Space and Site Hosting - Web Hosting - High Speed Internet
Search the Web

Monarch Assurance Plc Claret Jug Trophy

    Last revised: 18 January, 2004.    

Isle of Man Chess Association

Southern Chess Club

 

Links to Web-Pages
HOME PAGE
Club Competitions / News
Chess Links
Game of the Week
Latest Newspaper Reports
Manx Championships
Monarch Plc Claret Jug
Monarch 2003
Monarch 2002
Neville Gill - (British 2003)
Prizes 2002 / 3
Schools Chess

 

Visitor Number                 Visitor Number

http://www.fxweb.com/tracker/index.shtml


Holt Trophy tournament report season 2000/2001

Monarch Trophy - season 2002 / 2003


   

 Neville Gill, last year’s winner, retained the Monarch Claret Jug in fine style, being undefeated with 4½ points from 5 games.  Final scores: Gill 4½; Ware 3½; Waugh, Cross 3, Robertson 1; Mylrea 0.

     

Cross-table

Player Grade Gill Ware Waugh Cross Rob Myl Points A B C
Neville Gill 190 X 1 1 ½ 1 1 4 750 188
Mike Ware 115 0 X ½ 1 1 1 4 610 153
Jonathan Waugh 145 0 ½ X ½ 1 1 3 4 560 140
Glenn Cross 149 ½ 0 ½ X 1 1 3 4 560 140
Alan Robertson 111 0 0 0 0 X 1 1 4 360 90
Richard Mylrea - 0 0 0 0 0 X 0 5 - -
A - Number of games against graded opponents;  B - Grading points;  
C - Tournament performance (not known for Mylrea)
The Cross / Ware figures are distorted because of the artificial result of their game.

   

With Mike Ware just half a point behind, Neville had to go all out for a win against Alan Robertson in the final round.  Neville duly won his game, the four Bishops effectively deciding the outcome.  Neville’s Bishops were well placed, but two injudicious Bishop moves by Alan cost him much material.
White: Gill; Black: Robertson; 1.d4 Nf6  2.c4 c5  3.d5 d6  4.Nc3 g6  5.e4 Bg7  6.Bd3 0-0  7.Bg5 e6  8.dxe6 Bxe6  9.f4 Re8  10.Nf3 Na6  11.0-0 Bg4  12.h3 Bd7?  13.e5 dxe5  14.fxe5 Qb6  15.exf6 Bxf6  16.Nd5      1-0

   

Glenn Cross defeated Richard Mylrea.  It is surprising how often the same theme can occur as for the second time in the tournament Glenn won the game by making use of a strong Knight to devastating effect in a King side attack.
White: Mylrea; Black: Cross; 1.d4 Nf6  2.Bg5 e6  3.e4 Be7  4.e5 Nd5  5.Bxe7 Qxe7  6.a3 c5  7.Bc4 Nc7  8.c3 0-0  9.Nf3 d5  10.Bd3 cxd4  11.Nxd4 Nc6  12.Nxc6 bxc6  13.0-0 c5  14.b3 Bb7  15.Nd2 f6  16.Qh5 g6  17.Qe2 Rad8  18.exf6 Qxf6  19.c4 d4  20.b4 e5  21.bxc5 Ne6  22.Nb3? Nf4!  23.Qd2 Bxg2  24.Rfe1 Qg5     0-1

    

The game between Jonathan Waugh and Mike Ware ended in a draw after 33 moves, with Jonathan putting Mike’s King in perpetual check.  Mike missed a winning line towards the end of the game after Jonathan had sacrificed a Knight for a pawn.

Mike Ware

1.e4 c5  2.Nc3 d6  3.d3 Nf6  4.g3 g6  5.Bg2 Bg7  6.Be3 0-0  7.h3 Nc6  8.Qd2 Nd4  9.Nd1 e5  10.c3 Ne6  11.Ne2 Rb8  12.0-0 b5  13.d4 Qc7  14.d5 Nd8  15.f4 Ba6  16.fxe5 dxe5  17.b3 Nb7  18.g4 Nd6  19.Ng3 b4  20.c4 Bc8  21.Bh6 Nfe8  22.Nf2 Bd7  23.Nd3 f6  24.Be3 Nb7  25.Rf2 Ned6  26.Raf1 Rf7  27.Nxe5?!

Position after White's 27th move - See Diagram

27.......fxe5  28.Bh6 Bxh6  29.Qxh6 Rxf2  30.Rxf2 Nf7(a) 31.Rxf7 Kxf7  32.Qxh7+ Kf8  33.Qh8+ (b)

½-½

a) 30.......Qd8 followed by Qe7 leaves Black in a winning position!

Jonathan Waugh

(b) if 33........Ke7  34.Qh4+ Ke8  35.Qh8+

     


 

Round 4 - 28th November 2002.

With one round to go, Neville Gill, last year’s winner, took the outright lead in the Monarch Claret Jug Competition.  With Neville’s two closest rivals both losing, Neville has taken a clear lead and just needs a draw to win the trophy again when he plays Alan Robertson in the final round.  

In a delayed round 1 match, Mike Ware defeated Richard Mylrea and now moves up to second place!  Leading scores: Gill 3½, Ware 3, Waugh 2½, Cross 2.

 

In the big game of the fourth round, Jonathan Waugh surprised Neville Gill with a Grunfeld defence.  Neville met this in the same way as he did against John Tootill at Scarborough 2001, the game that won Neville the British Senior Championship that year.  It was extremely difficult for Jonathan to get any active play as he was pinned down defending his weak pawns, and when one of the pawns was about to fall, an oversight lost Jonathan the game immediately with Neville one move away from queening a pawn
White: Gill; Black: Waugh; 1.d4 Nf6  2.c4 g6  3.Nc3 d5  4.Nf3 Bg7  5.Bg5 Ne4  6.cxd5 Nxg5  7.Nxg5 e6  8.Nf3 exd5  9.e3 0-0  10.Be2 c6  11.0-0 Nd7  12.b4! a5  13.b5 Nf6  14.bxc6 bxc6  15.Na4 Ne4  16.Nd2 Be6  17.Nxe4 dxe4  18.Qc2 Bd5  19.Nc5 Qe7  20.Rab1 Rfb8  21.h3 h6  22.Qa4 Qa7  23.Bc4 Bf8  24.Bxd5 cxd5  25.Qc6 Bxc5  26.dxc5 Rd8  27.Rb7 Qa6  28.Qc7 Qf6  29.Rd1 Rdc8  30.Qb6 Rc6  31.Qb5 Rac8  32.Rb6 Rxb6  33.cxb6 Rc2  34.Rf1 Rxa2?(a)  35.b7 Resigns    1-0
(a) Correct was 34......Rb2  35.Qxa5 Qxb6  36.Qa8+ Qb8  37.Qxd5 with an extra pawn.  If 37......Qa7  38.Rc1 Qxa2  39.Rc8+ Kh7  40.Qe5

  

The battle for the wooden spoon between Alan Robertson and Richard Mylrea ended in a win for Alan as Richard gave away his queen after 13 moves.
1.d4 d5  2.Nf3 Bg4  3.Nc3 Bxf3  4.exf3 h6  5.f4 e6  6.a3 a6  7.Be3 Bd6  8.Be2 Qf6  9.g4 Bxf4  10.Qd2 Bxe3  11.Qxe3 Nc6  12.Nxd5 Nxd4?(loses the Queen)  13.Nxf6+ Nxf6  14.Qxd4 0-0  15.Qc3 Nd5  16.Qg3 g5  17.Rd1 Nf4  18.Bf3 c6  19.0-0 c5  20.Rfe1 Rb8  21.Rd7 b6  22.Red1 e5  23.h4 e4  24.hxg5 hxg5  25.Kf1 exf3  26.Qxf3 Ne6  27.c3 a5  28.Qf5 Ng7  29.Qxg5 Rfe8  30.Rxf7!    1-0

     

In the other game, Glenn Cross had to resign his game after about a dozen moves when he received an urgent telephone call and had to leave.  According to his opponent Mike Ware, the position was very interesting.

Mike Ware

1.d4 Nf6  2.c4 g6  3.Bf4 Bg7  4.Nc3 0-0  5.e3 d6  6.Bd3 Nh5  7.Bg5 h6  8.Bh4 g5  9.Bg3 Nxg3  10.hxg3 Nc6  11.Qh5 e5  12.d5 Ne7  13.Ne4 Ng6  14.Nf3 f5

See Diagram

 

Glenn Cross

      


Round 3 - 14th November 2002.

    

One of the key games of the tournament, Jonathan Waugh v Glenn Cross, ended in a draw.  The opening was a Sicilian defence, and Jonathan worked up a strong attack to win a Rook in exchange for a Knight and pawn, but the draw was agreed after 31 moves in a position where there was plenty of play left.
1.e4 c5  2.Nf3 Nf6  3.Nc3 d6  4.d4 cxd4  5.Nxd4 a6  6.Be2 Nc6  7.0-0 g6  8.Kh1 Bg7  9.Nxc6 bxc6  10.f4 Qc7  11.Bf3 Bb7  12.Be3 0-0  13.Qe1 Nd7  14.Qf2 f5  15.Rad1 fxe4  16.Nxe4 d5  17.Ng5 Qd6  18.Bg4 Nf6  19.Be6+ Kh8  20.Bc5 Qc7  21.f5 Bh6  22.Nf7+ Kg7  23.Nxh6 Kxh6  24.Rd3 Bc8  25.Be3+ Kg7  26.Qh4 Bxe6  27.fxe6 Qe5  28.Bh6+ Kg8  29.Bxf8 Rxf8  30.Rdf3 Qxe6  31.Qa4 c5  Draw agreed   ½-½

     

Castling on the Queen’s side can be a risky business and this was demonstrated strongly in the Mike Ware, Alan Robertson game.  After last weeks poor start in the competition, Mike played his, quote, “best game in 3 years” and blew his opponent away with some vigorous moves to which Alan could find no answers.
1.e4 g6  2.d4 Bg7  3.c3 d6  4.Nf3 Nf6  5.Bd3 Nbd7  6.Bg5 c6  7.0-0 Qc7  8.Qd2 a5  9.Bh6 Bxh6  10.Qxh6 Qb6  11.Qd2 h6  12.Na3 Qc7  13.Nc4 b5  14.Ne3 Bb7  15.Rfe1 0-0-0  16.a4 b4  17.cxb4 axb4  18.Qxb4 Qb6  19.Qc3 Qa7  20.a5 Nb8  21.Nc4 Nfd7  22.b4 Ba6  23.h3 Bb5  24.d5 Qa6  25.Nd4 Ne5  26.Nb6+ Kb7  27.dxc6+ Nbxc6  28.Bxb5 Qxb5  29.Nxb5 e6  30.Rec1 f5  31.Nd4 Rh7  32.Nxe6 Rb8  33.f4 Nxb4  34.fxe5    1-0

   

Neville Gill also castled long (Queen’s side) but here there was absolutely no danger for Neville.  Richard Mylrea held on very well until move 40, when a faulty exchange of Bishops led to a lost King and pawn ending.
1.e4 e5  2.Nf3 Nc6  3.Bb5 a6  4.Bxc6 dxc6  5.Nxe5 Qd4  6.Nf3 Qxe4+  7.Qe2 Qxe2+  8.Kxe2 Nf6  9.Rd1 Be7  10.h3 Bf5  11.d3 0-0-0  12.Ng5 Bg6  13.a3 Rhe8  14.Kf1 Bd6  15.Nc3 Rxe1+  16.Kxe1 Re8+  17.Kf1 h6  18.Nf3 Nd5  19.Bd2 Nxc3  20.Bxc3 f6  21.Nh4 Bh7  22.g4 Kd7  23.Re1 Rxe1+  24.Kxe1 Ke6  25.Ke2 c5  26.Ke3 b5  27.f4 b4  28.f5+ Kd5  29.axb4 cxb4  30.Bd2 a5  31.c3 bxc3  32.Bxc3 a4  33.Nf3 c5  34.Nd2 Bg8  35.Nc4 Bc7  36.Na3 Kc6  37.Nc4 Bd5  38.Kf2 Bf4  39.h4 Bc7  40.Ba5? Bxa5  41.Nxa5+ Kb5  42.Nc4 Bxc4  43.dxc4 Kxc4  44.Ke3 Kb3  45.Kf4 Kxb2  46.g5 a3  47.gah6 gxh6  48.Kg4 a2  49.Kh5 a1(Q)  50.Kxh6 Qg1    0-1

    

Leading scores: Gill, Waugh 2½, Cross 2.  In round 4 the top two players meet each other!

 


Round 2 - 7th November 2002.

Mike Ware playing his first game in the competition lost very quickly against reigning champion Neville Gill who was on top form.  Mike played his moves in the wrong order, moving a Knight a second time before castling and the result was catastrophic.  Neville sacrificed a Bishop and checkmated Mike with Knight and Queen after only 11 moves.

Mike Ware

Neville Gill v Mike Ware round 2

1.d4 d5  2.c4 dxc4  3.Nf3 Nf6  4.e3 g6  5.Bxc4 Bg7  6.Nc3 Nfd7!?(a)  7.Bxf7+ 

SEE DIAGRAM

7......Kxf7(b)  8.Ng5+ Kg8  9.Qb3+ e6  10.Qxe6+ Kf8 11.Qf7#     1-0

(a) Nfd7 (with the idea of Nb6) is standard play in this variation, but Black must castle first.

(b) Taking the Bishop leads to checkmate or loss of the Queen, but 7......Kf8 leaves him a pawn down and a wrecked position.

Neville Gill

    

Richard Mylrea had some good ideas in his game against Jonathan Waugh, but he lapsed here and there.  This is what happens when you have not played for several years, and the inevitable lapse too many came on move 28 and he was checkmated by Jonathan 2 moves later.

Jonathan Waugh

Richard Mylrea v Jonathan Waugh round 2

1.d4 Nf6  2.Bg5 g6  3.Bxf6 exf6  4.e3 Bg7  5.Nf3 0-0  6.h3 d5  7.c4 c6  8.c5 Re8  9.Nc3 Nd7  10.b4 f5  11.Be2 h6  12.0-0 g5  13.Nh2 Nf6  14.g4 Qc7  15.Qd3 Ne4  16.f3?

SEE DIAGRAM

16......Qg3+  17.Kh1 Nf2+  18.Rxf2 Qxf2  19.Nd1 Qg3  20.Bf1 f4  21.b5 Bd7  22.bxc6 bxc6  23.Rb1 fxe3  24.Nxe4 Qf4  25.Ng2 Qxd4  26.Rb7 Be6  27.Qa6 Qf2  28.Qxc6 Bd4       0-1

Richard Mylrea

    

In the Alan Robertson / Glenn Cross game, not too much of note occurred, until Glenn was allowed to advance his Knight onto a favourable square.  He then won material by pinning Alan’s Rook against an undefended Queen leading to an end game with Rook and Bishop against Rook, which was a very easy win for Glenn.

Glenn Cross

Alan Robertson v Glenn Cross round 2

1.e4 c5  2.Nf3 d6  3.c3 Bg4  4.Bb5+ Nd7  5.d3 a6  6.Ba4 b5  7.Bc2 e6  8.Bf4 Be7  9.Nbd2 Ngf6  10.h3 Bxf3  11.Nxf3 0-0  12.0-0 Qb6  13.Qd2 Rfc8  14.Rfe1 e5  15.Bg5 Ra7  16.Nh2 Nf8  17.Ng4 Nxg4  18.Bxe7 Rxe7  19.hxg4 Ne6  20.Re3 Nf4  21.Kh2 d5  22.g3 Qh6+

SEE DIAGRAM

23.Kg1 d4 24.gxf4 Qxf4  25.Bd1 dxe3  26.Qxe3 Qxe3  27.fxe3 Re6  28.Rc1 Rg6  29.Rc2 Rd8  30.d4 exd4  31.exd4 h5  32.d5 hxg4  33.Rg2 g3  34.Bf3 Re8  35.Kf1 Kf8  36.Re2 Re5  37.Kg2 Ke7  38.b3 Kd6  39.c4 Reg5  40.cxb5 axb5  41.a4 bxa4  42.bxa4 Rh6  43.a5 Rh2+  44.Kg1 Rxe2  45.Bxe2 Re5  46.Bf3 c4  47.a6 Re7  48.e5+ Kxe5  49.Kg2 c3  50.Be4 Kxe4  51.d6 Rd7  52.Kxg3 c2      0-1

Alan Robertson

   

John Griffin had the bye.  Leading scores: Waugh 2, Cross & Gill 1½.  In round 3 Waugh v Cross will hold centre stage.        (Report by Neville Gill)

    


Round 1 - 31st October 2002.

Neville Gill reports that the first round of the Isle of Man Chess Association Monarch Claret Jug competition took place on Thursday 31st October at the Hilton Hotel, Douglas, with a disappointing entry of just 7 players.        Mike Ware had the bye.

 

Richard Mylrea, making a comeback after many years, was white against John Griffin.  After a swings and roundabout struggle, John won with a deadly pin on a diagonal.

John Griffin

Richard Mylrea v John Griffin Round 1

1.e4 e6  2.e5 b6  3.d4 Bb7  4.Nf3 d5  5.a3 c5  6.dxc5 Bxc5  7.b4 Be7  8.Bb5+ Bc6  9.Qd3 Qc7  10.Nd4 Qxe5+  11.Be3 Nf6  12.f4 Qc7  13.0-0 a6  14.Nxc6 Nxc6  15.Bxa6 0-0  16.Nd2 Ra7  17.b5 Nb8  18.c4 Ng4  19.cxd5

SEE DIAGRAM

19....... Nxe3  20.Qxe3 Bc5 (the Queen is lost) 21.Qxc5 Qxc5+  22.Kh1 Qxd5  23.Rad1 Nxa6       

0-1

Richard Mylrea

 

The opening of the game between Jonathan Waugh and Alan Robertson was a French Defence.  Jonathan placed his pieces on their best squares and sacrificed a Rook and Knight to force mate.  Combinative play of this kind is not often seen in local chess, and if there was a best game prize in this tournament then this game would have to be a candidate.

Alan Robertson

Jonathan Waugh v Alan Robertson round 1

1.d4 e6  2.e4 d5  3.Nd2 c5  4.exd5 Qxd5  5.dxc5 Bxc5  6.Ngf3 Nf6  7.Be2 0-0  8.0-0 Bb6  9.c4 Qd8  10.b3 Nc6  11.Bb2 Re8  12.Ne5 Qc7  13.Ndf3 Rd8  14.Qc2 Nxe5  15.Nxe5 Bd7  16.Bf3 Be8  17.h3 Nd7  18.Qc3 f6  19.Ng4 a5  20.Rad1 Bc5  21.a3 Bf8  22.Rd2 Rab8  23.Rfd1 Rdc8

SEE DIAGRAM

24.Rxd7 Bxd7  25.Nxf6+ gxf6  26.Qxf6 Be8  27.Qh8+ Kf7  28.Bh5+ Ke7  29.Bf6#      

  1-0

Jonathan Waugh

   

Glenn Cross and Neville Gill played a fairly correct but rather dull Queens Gambit declined.  Glenn found an excellent defensive plan, bringing his Bishop back from g5 to e1.  Neville got down to an ending with Bishop versus Knight but there was no way to break through.
1.d4 d5  2.c4 e6  3.Nc3 Nf6  4.Bg5 Be7  5.e3 Nbd7  6.Nf3 0-0  7.Bd3 dxc4  8.Bxc4 c5  9.dxc5 Nxc5  10.0-0 a6  11.a3 b5  12.Ba2 Bb7  13.Nd4 Qb6  14.Rc1 Rfd8  15.Qe2 h6  16.Bh4 Rac8  17.f3 b4  18.axb4 Qxb4  19.Be1 Qb6  20.b4 Ncd7  21.Na4 Qa7  22.Rxc8 Rxc8  23.Qb2 Nd5  24.Bd2 Bf6  25.Kh1 N5b6  26.Bb3 Nxa4  27.Bxa4 Nb6  28.Bb3 Nc4  29.Bxc4 Rxc4  30.Bc3 Bd5  31.Rd1 Qc7  32.Rd3 g5  33.Ne2 Bxc3  34.Rxc3 Rxc3  35.Qxc3 Qc4     ½-½

 

Monarch Assurance Plc


Monarch Trophy - season 2001 / 2002

IoMCA (Cherry Orchard) the new Monarch Assurance Plc Claret Jug - 2 hours per player per game.  The competition arbiter is Neville Gill.  The new 2 minute rule to apply, in which the result can be decided by the arbiter!


MONARCH ASSURANCE Plc CLARET JUG

Isle of Man Chess Association - Season 2001 / 2002

Neville Gill has added further to his list of chess successes by winning the initial competition for the Monarch Assurance Claret Jug which has superseded the Holt Trophy. 

Neville Gill receives the "retired" Holt Trophy from Patrick Taylor.  Since 1977, Neville has won the trophy 18 times from the 25 competitions held.

Neville Gill receives the  "New" Monarch Assurance Claret Jug from Patrick Taylor.

To be sure of victory Neville needed a draw in the final round against Jonathan Waugh and this he secured.  Post game analysis showed that he might have missed a win in a tricky ending which eventually came down to a knight against a lone pawn.  This left Jonathan in second place half a point behind after seven rounds.

Third place was decided between Alan Robertson and Frank Maher where Frank needed a win to overhaul a half point advantage enjoyed by Alan.  A tactical finesse which allowed Frank to break through on the queen side, after repulsing Alan’s attack on the other wing, gave Frank the victory.

Richard Sargent filled the fifth berth without any worries as he had the bye.  The final game of the evening to decide the remaining places was fought out between Mike Ware and John Griffin.  Playing white, Mike had much the better of the game all through but blundered at the end into a simple mate.       TROMPOWSKI

Final Crosstable

Pos Player Grd Rd1 2 3 4 5 6 7 A B C D
1 Gill, Neville 192 B5+ Bye+ W3+ B7+ W6+ B4+ W2= 6 1162 194
2 Waugh, Jonathan 143 W3+ B7= W6+ B4+ Bye+ W5+ B1= 6 6 947 158
3 Maher, Frank 127 B2- W5+ B1- Bye+ W7+ B6= W4+ 6 797 133
4 Robertson, Alan 108 W7+ B6+ Bye+ W2- B5+ W1- B3- 4 6 747 125
5 Sargent, Richard 110 W1- B3- W7+ B6+ W4- B2- Bye+ 3 6 647 108
6 Griffin, John 105 Bye+ W4- B2- W5- B1- W3= B7+ 6 597 100
7 Ware, Michael 114 B4- W2= B5- W1- B3- Bye+ W6- 6 497 83

Grd = Manx Grade
A = Player score (Bye = 1 point)
B = Number of graded games played
C = Total grading points (same system as BCF)
D = Grading performance for tournament

Venue: Cherry Orchard Hotel, Port Erin Oct-Dec 2001.   Format: All-play-all              

 Arbiter: Neville Gill.   Time limit: All moves in 2 hours.

  ____________________________________________________________________

 

Final Round (7) Fixtures  -  Wednesday 12th December 2001.

The final round fixtures are all crucial to the final results.  Neville Gill and Jonathan Waugh play for 1st and 2nd places.  Frank Maher and Alan Robertson for 3rd and 4th places.  Richard Sargent with the Bye will finish 5th on 3 points and Mike Ware and John Griffin play for the "wooden spoon".                         ZUGZWANG

Round 7 results

Neville Gill (6) ½-½ Jonathan Waugh (5½)
Frank Maher (3½) 1-0 Alan Robertson (4)
Mike Ware (1½) 0-1 John Griffin (1½)
Richard Sargent (2)  Bye

 

White: Neville Gill v Black: Jonathan Waugh      (E97 Kings Indian)
1. d4 Nf6  2. c4 g6  3. Nc3 Bg7  4. e4 d6  5. Be2 0-0  6. Nf3 e5  7. 0-0 Nc6  8. Be3 Ng4  9. Bg5 f6
10. Bh4 Ne7  11. h3 Nh6  12. Qd2 c6  13. Rad1 Qe8  14. dxe5 dxe5  15. Qd6 Nf7  16. Qc7 g5
17. Bg3 Ng6  18. c5 Qe7  19. Qxe7 Nxe7  20. Bc4 Re8  21. Rd3 Bf8  22. Bxe5 Kg7  23. Bd6 Ng6
24. Bxf8+ Kxf8  25. Bxf7 Kxf7  26. Rfd1 Ne5  27. Nxe5+ Rxe5  28. Rd8 Re8  29. f3 h5
30. Kf2 h4  31. Ke3 Be6  32. Rxa8 Rxa8  33. Rd6 Re8  34. Kd4 Bc8  35. b4 a6  36. a4 Re7
37. b5 axb5  38. axb5 Rd7  39. bxc6 bxc6  40. e5 Rad6+  41. cxd6 Ke6  42. Kc5 Kxe5
43. Kxc6 Kf4  44. Nd5+ Kg3  45. Nxf6 Kxg2  46. Nh7 Kxh3  47. Nxg5+ Kg3  48. d7 Bxd7+
49. Kxd7 Kf4  50. Nh3+ Kxf3  51. Ke6      ½-½

 

White: Frank Maher v Black: Alan Robertson          (D53 Queens gambit declined)
1. c4 e6  2. d4 d5  3. Nc3 Nf6  4. Bg5 Be7  5. Nf3 Nbd7  6. e3 h6  7. Bh4 c6  8. Qc2 Qa5  
9. Bd3 b5(a)  10. cxb5 cxb5  11. Bxb5 Ba6  12. Bxa6 Qxa6  13. Qe2 Qb7  14. 0-0 0-0
15. Rfc1 Rfc8  16. Rc2 Rc6  17. Rac1 g5  18. Bg3 Rac8  19. h4 Nh7  20. hxg5 hxg5  21. Nh2 Ndf6
22. f4 Qc7  23. fxg5 Qxg3  24. gxf6 Nxf6  25. Qf3 Qg6  26. Rf2 Ne4  27. Rfc2 f5  28. Qe2 Ng3
29. Qf2 Bd6  30. Nf1 Nh5  31. Nb5 Rxc2  32. Rxc2 Rxc2  33. Qxc2 Bf8  34. Nxa7 Nf6
35. Nc6 Ne4  36. a4 Bd6  37. Ne5 Qe8  38. a5 Be7  39. Qc6 Qd8(b)  40. Qxe6+      1-0
(a) ??       (b) ??

 

White: Mike Ware v Black: John Griffin    (D02 Queens Bishop game)
1. Nf3 d5  2. d4 Bf5  3. Bg5 Nf6  4. Nbd2 c5  5. e3 Nc6  6. dxc5 e6  7. Nb3 Bxc5  8. Bxf6 gxf6
9. Nxc5 Qa5+  10. c3 Qxc5  11. Nd4 Be4  12. Qg4 Ke7  13. Qf4 e5  14. Nf5+ Kd7  15. Qg4 Ne7
16. Ng3+ f5  17. Qg7 f4  18. Nxe4 dxe4  19. Rd1+ Ke6  20. exf4 Ng6  21. f5+ Kxf5  22. Qxf7+ Kg5
23. Qc4 Qb6  24. Qxe4 Qxb2  25. Qe3+ Kf6  26. Qf3+ Ke7  27. Bc4 Rhf8  28. Qg3 Rac8
29. Qg5+ Rf6  30. Bb3 Qxf2#

 


Round 6

Stage set for nail-biting chess final

The penultimate round of the Monarch Assurance Trophy saw the two players who head the leader board maintain their positions as both Neville Gill and Jonathan Waugh won their games to leave the former still half a point in front.

Neville gained a strong advantage in his game with Alan Robertson while his opponent was encumbered with an isolated pawn and later doubled pawns as well.  That was two weaknesses too many and Alan paid the inevitable price.

Jonathan Waugh's Ruy Lopez left himself and Richard Sargent with a balanced position, though Jonathan had a superior outpost for a knight on f5 which allowed him to mount a successful king side attack, winning a rook.

A most unbalanced position arose from John Griffin's early sacrifice of a bishop for which he gained three of Frank Maher's pawns.  Eventually John had a rook and pawn opposing a rook and knight and a draw was agreed as neither player could force a win.

The bye went to Mike Ware and the final round has ideal pairings as Neville Gill and Jonathan Waugh play each other for first place, as do Alan Robertson and Frank Maher for third.  Richard Sargent has the bye and comes fifth, while Mike Ware and John Griffin battle it out to finish off the bottom.  Everybody has a lot to play for, so expect some nail-biting action.

TROMPOWSKI

Crosstable after round 6

Pos Player Grade Rnd 1 Rnd 2 Rnd 3 Rnd 4 Rnd 5 Rnd 6 Total
1 Gill, Neville 192 5+ Bye+ 4+ 7+ 6+ 3+ 6
2 Waugh, Jonathan 143 4+ 7= 6+ 3+ Bye+ 5+
3 Robertson, Alan 108 7+ 6+ Bye+ 2- 5+ 1- 4
4 Maher, Frank 127 2- 5+ 1- Bye+ 7+ 6=
5 Sargent, Richard 110 1- 4- 7+ 6+ 3- 2- 2
6 Griffin, John 105 Bye+ 3- 2- 5- 1- 4=
7 Ware, Mike 114 3- 2= 5- 1- 4- Bye+
8 Bye - 6- 1- 3- 4- 2- 7- 0

Round 6 results

John Griffin (1) ½-½ Frank Maher (3)
Alan Robertson (4) 0-1 Neville Gill (5)
Jonathan Waugh (4½) 1-0 Richard Sargent (2)
Mike Ware (½)  Bye

 

White: John Griffin v Black:  Frank Maher       (C41 Philidor variation)
1. e4 e5  2. Nf3 d6  3. Nc3 g6  4. d4 Nd7  5. Bc4 Nb6  6. Bb3 Bg4  7. Bxf7+ Kxf7  8. dxe5 Bxf3
9. Qxf3+ Kg7  10. e6 Qf6  11. Qh3 Re8  12. Nd5 Qxe6  13. Qc3+ Qe5  14. Qxc7+ Be7  
15. Nxb6 Qxe4+  16. Be3 axb6  17. 0-0-0 Qc6  18. Bxb6 Qxc7  19. Bxc7 Nf6  20. Bxd6 Bxd6
21. Rxd6 Re7  22. f3 Rhe8  23. c4 Re2  24. Rd2 Re1+  25. Rxe1 Rxe1+  26. Kc2 Kf7  27. Kb3 Ke7
28. Ka4 Re5  29. b4 b6  30. Rd4 Re2  31. Kb5 Rxg2  32. Kxb6 Rxa2  33. h4 Ra3  34. c5 Rxf3
35. c6 Rc3  36. Kb7 Ne8  37. Rd7+ Ke6  38. Rxh7 Rb3  39. Rh6 Rxb4+  40. Kc8 Kf7  
41. Rh7+ Ke6  42. h5 gxh5  43. Rxh5 Rc4  44. Rh6+ Ke7  45. Rg6 Nd6+  46. Kc7 Ne8+
47. Kb6 Kd8  48. Rg5 Rb4+  49. Kc5 Rb1  50. Rd5+ Kc8  51. Rd7 Rc1+  52. Kb6 Rb1+
53. Ka6 Ra1+  54. Kb5 Rb1+       ½-½

   

White: Alan Robertson v Black: Neville Gill      (A13 English opening)
1. c4 e6  2. e4 d5  3. cxd5 exd5  4. exd5 Nf6  5. Nc3 Nxd5  6. d4 Be7  7. Nge2 0-0  8. g3 Nc6
9. Bg2 Be6  10. 0-0 Qd7  11. Re1 Rfe8  12. Be3 Rad8  13. Qd2 Nxc3  14. bxc3 Bd5
15. f3 Na5  16. Qc2 Nc4  17. Bf2 Bg5  18. Nf4 Bxf4  19. gxf4 Be6  20. Bh4 f6  21. Bf1 Qd5
22. Qg2 Kh8  23. Rac1 Bf7  24. Bd3 Nd6  25. Qh3 Qh5  26. f5 Bxa2  27. Rc2 Rxe1+      0-1

  

White: Jonathan Waugh  v Black: Richard Sargent   (C78 Ruy Lopez)
1. e4 e5  2. Nf3 Nc6  3. Bb5 a6  4. Ba4 Nf6  5. 0-0 Bc5  6. d3 b5  7. Bb3 0-0  8. c3 h6
9. Nbd2 Re8  10. Qe2 Bb6  11. h3 d6  12. Re1 Bd7  13. Nf1 Na5  14. Bc2 Qc8  15. Kh2 c6
16. Ng3 Nb7  17. Nh4 Kh7  18. Ngf5 g5  19. Qd2 Bxf5  20. Nxf5 Ng8  21. Qe2 Re6
22. Bd2 f6  23. Bb3 Ne7  24. Qh5 Nxf5  25. exf5 Qe8  26. Qg6+ Qxg6  27. fxg6+ Kxg6
28. Bxe6 Bxf2(a)  29. Rf1 Bb6  30. Bf5+ Kg7  31. Rf3 Bd8  32. Bd7 c5  33. Bc6 Rb8
34. Bxb7 Rxb7  35. b4 cxb4  36. cxb4 Rc7  37. Rc1 Rb7  38. Rc6 Ra7  39. Rf1 a5  40. bxa5 Bxa5
41. Bxa5 Rxa5  42. Rc2       1-0
(a) Black loses a Rook for 2 pawns

 


Round 5 - 21st November 2001.

Alan recovers to pounce on Queen and record victory

Having come off the worse against Jonathan Waugh in a roller-coaster game the previous week Alan Robertson had another similar try with Richard Sargent in the fifth round of the Monarch chess trophy, this time with more success. Richard engineered a good aggressive game from his Colle opening but missed two opportunities to convert the advantage into material gain. The third opportunity fell Alan's way and he made no mistake in pouncing on Richard's queen.

Neville Gill had a relatively easy win over John Griffin in a queen's gambit declined when John, playing black, neglected development for the excitement of repeatedly moving his queen and knight. The result was that his king got caught in the centre and Neville won decisive material as early as move 17.

The longest game of the night lasting 58 moves arose from Frank Maher's English opening defended by Mike Ware. Mike had a cramped game from the beginning which later saddled him with a backward pawn on an open queen's file. This is invariably the precursor to a slow death and so it proved. When mate was delivered by Frank he had only one minute 14 seconds left in which to finish the game with Mike's clock showing three seconds less. Exciting stuff but somewhat inevitable.

Jonathan Waugh collected the bye and with two rounds to be completed the leading scores are:- N Gill 5 pts; J Waugh 4½; A Robertson 4; F Maher 3; R Sargent 2.      TROMPOWSKI

Crosstable after round 5

Pos Player Grade Rnd 1 Rnd 2 Rnd 3 Rnd 4 Rnd 5 Total
1 Gill, Neville 192 5+ Bye+ 4+ 7+ 6+ 5
2 Waugh, Jonathan 143 4+ 7= 6+ 3+ Bye+
3 Robertson, Alan 108 7+ 6+ Bye+ 2- 5+ 4
4 Maher, Frank 127 2- 5+ 1- Bye+ 7+ 3
5 Sargent, Richard 110 1- 4- 7+ 6+ 3- 2
6 Griffin, John 105 Bye+ 3- 2- 5- 1- 1
7 Ware, Mike 114 3- 2= 5- 1- 4- ½
8 Bye - 6- 1- 3- 4- 2- 0

Round 5 results

Richard Sargent (2) 0-1 Alan Robertson (3)
Neville Gill (4) 1-0 John Griffin (1)
Frank Maher (2)  1-0 Mike Ware (½) 
Jonathan Waugh (3½) Bye

 

White: Richard Sargent v Black: Alan Robertson          (D05 Colle System)
1. d4 d5  2. Nf3 Nf6  3. e3 e6  4. Bd3 c5  5. c3 Be7  6. 0-0 0-0  7. Nbd2 Bd7  8. Re1 Bc6  
9. dxc5 Bxc5  10. b4 Be7  11. Ne5 Qd6  12. Nxc6 Nxc6  13. f4 Bd8  14. b5 Ne7  15. a4 Bb6
16. Nf3 Rfc8  17. c4 Ba5  18. Ba3 Bb4  19. Bxb4 Qxb4  20. Rb1 Qc5  21. Rc1 a6  22. bxa6 bxa6
23. cxd5 Qxd5  24. Rxc8+ Nxc8  25. Qc2 Nd6  26. e4 Qa5  27. e5 Rc8  28. Qb1 Ng4  29. Re2 Qc5+
30. Kf1 Nc4  31. Ke1 Nxh2  32. Bxc4 Nxf3+  33. gxf3 Qg1+        0-1

 

White: Neville Gill v Black: John Griffin    (D31 Queen's gambit declined)
1. d4 d5  2. c4 e6  3. Nc3 Bb4  4. a3 Bxc3+  5. bxc3 c5  6. cxd5 Qxd5  7. e3 Nf6  8. Nf3 Ne4
9. c4 Qh5  10. Bd3 Qg6  11. 0-0 Nc6  12. d5 Ne7  13. Ne5 Qf6  14. Qa4+ Kf8  15. Bb2 exd5 
16. cxd5 Nd2  17. Ng6+ hxg6  18. Bxf6 gxf6  19. Rfd1 Nf3+  20. gxf3 Nxd5  21. Bxg6 Nc3 
22. Qc4 Ne2+  23. Qxe2 Rg8  24. Rd8+       1-0 

 

White: Frank Maher v Black: Mike Ware          (A10 English opening)
1. c4 b6  2. Nc3 Bb7  3. e4 e5  4. g3 Nf6  5. Bg2 Be7  6. b3 d6  7. Bb2 Nbd7  8. Nge2 Nc5
9. Qc2 Na6  10. d4 Nb4  11. Qd1 exd4  12. Nxd4 Nc6  13. Nf5 Bf8  14. 0-0 g6  15. Ne3 Bg7
16. Ncd5 0-0  17. Nxf6+ Bxf6  18. Bxf6 Qxf6  19. Nd5 Qd8  20. Qc2 Ne5  21. Qc3 c6  22. Ne3 Qf6 
23. Kh1 Rad8  24. Rad1 Qe7  25. Rd2 Nd7  26. Rfd1 Nf6  27. f3 c5  28. Re2 Qe5  29. Qe1 a6 
30. a4 Qe8  31. Qc3 Qe6  32. Rde1 Qe5  33. Qc1 h5  34. Kg1 Kh7  35. f4 Qe6  36. Nd5 Nd7 
37. Qc2 Bxd5  38. exd5 Qf6  39. Re7 Kg7  40. Bh3 Qd4+  41. Kf1 Nf6  42. Rd1(a) Qxd1+ 
43. Qxd1 Rde8  44. Qe2 Rd8  45. Rb7 Rfe8  46. Be6 Kh6  47. Rxf7 Rf8  48. Rxf8 Rxf8  49. Qf3 Kg7
50. f5 g5  51. Qe3 Kh6  52. h4 Ng4  53. Qxg5+ Kh7  54. Qxh5+ Kg7  55. Qxg4+ Kh7 
56. Qh5+ Kg7  57. Qg6+ Kh8  58. Qh6#     1-0 
(a) The black queen is lost and the game is effectively over, but Mike plays to the bitter end!

 


Round 4 - 14th November 2001.

Roller coaster rides in Monarch chess

The fourth round of the Monarch trophy resulted in Neville Gill taking a clear lead when he won his game while Alan Robertson, who had been sharing top berth with him, lost out to Jonathan Waugh.

Alan Robertson had a real roller coaster of a game against Jonathan Waugh when he exchanged a knight for three pawns leaving him with four against one on the queen's side. He then launched a king side attack and when he and Jonathan both had about ten minutes left to finish the game they started playing very quickly as if they were in extreme time trouble. So much so that Alan made an illegal move which was not spotted by Jonathan who, however, delivered checkmate a few moves later.

Another game of lost opportunities was that between John Griffin and Richard Sargent. John's favourite Sokolsky opening gave him the strong advantage of two pawns up. Then, in a relatively simple position, he walked into a mate much to Richard's relief.

Neville Gill does not play like that. Instead he made steady progress as black against Mike Ware, first winning one pawn and then another and continued steadily, delivering mate on move 57.  No fireworks, no mistakes, another point!

Frank Maher had the bye making the leading scores after four rounds:- N Gill 4; J Waugh 3½; A Robertson 3; F Maher and R Sargent 2.                                   TROMPOWSKI

 

Crosstable after round 4

Pos Player Grade Rnd 1 Rnd 2 Rnd 3 Rnd 4 Total
1 Gill, Neville 192 5+ Bye+ 4+ 7+ 4
2 Waugh, Jonathan 143 4+ 7= 6+ 3+
3 Robertson, Alan 108 7+ 6+ Bye+ 2- 3
4= Maher, Frank 127 2- 5+ 1- Bye+ 2
5= Sargent, Richard 110 1- 4- 7+ 6+ 2
6 Griffin, John 105 Bye+ 3- 2- 5- 1
7 Ware, Mike 114 3- 2= 5- 1- ½
8 Bye - 6- 1- 3- 4- 0

  

Round 4 results

Mike Ware (½)  0-1 Neville Gill (3)
John Griffin (1) 0-1 Richard Sargent (1)
Alan Robertson (3) 0-1 Jonathan Waugh (2½)
Frank Maher (1)  Bye

   Round 4 games - score sheets

White: Alan Robertson v Black: Jonathan Waugh   (C20 Kings pawn game)
1. e4 e5  2. Bb5 Be7  3. Nf3 c6  4. Ba4 d6  5. 0-0 Nf6  6. Re1 0-0  7. d4 Nbd7  8. Nc3 b5  9. Bb3 Bb7
10. a3 Qc7  11. Bg5 Rfe8  12. Qd2 a6  13. Bh4 Rad8  14. Bg3 Nh5  15. Ne2 c5  16. d5 c4  17. Ba2 Nc5
18. Nc3 Rf8  19. Qe2 Nxg3  20. hxg3 Bc8  21. Nd1 f5  22. exf5 Bxf5  23. Ne3 Bg6  24. Rad1 Qc8
25. Nxc4 bxc4  26. Bxc4 Bh5  27. b4 Na4  28. Bxa6 Qg4  29. Qd2 Qf5  30. Bd3 Qf7  31. c4 Bxf3
32. gxf3 Qxf3  33. Qc2 Nb6  34. Bxh7+ Kh8  35. Re3 Qh5  36. Bg6 Qh3  37. Qe2 Rf6  38. g4 Qh4
39. Bf5(a) Rh6  40. Qf3 Nxc4  41. Re4 Nb6  42. Qg2 Bg5  43. b5 Bf4  44. Kf1 Qg5  45. Qf3 Ra8
46. Ke2 Rh2  47. Rh1 Nxd5  48. Rxh2+ Bxh2  49. Qh3+ Qh6  50. Qb3 Nf4+ 51. Kd1 Qh3 52. f3 Qf1+
53. Re1 Qf2  54. Be4 Qd4+  55. Kc2 Rc8+  56. Bc6 Qf2+  57. Kd1 Ng2  58. Re2 Qf1+  59. Kd2 Bf4+
60. Kd3 Ne1+  61. Rxe1(b) Qxe1  62. Kc4 Qd2  63. a4 Qd4++        0-1
(a) Kg2 must be better
(b) Illegal move not noticed by either player!

 

White: John Griffin  v Black: Richard Sargent   (A00 Sokolsky)
1. b4 e5  2. Bb2 d6  3. e4 Nf6  4. Nc3 b6  5. Bc4 Bb7  6. d3 a6  7. Nh3 b5  8. Bb3 h6  9. a4 c6
10. 0-0 Be7  11. f4 Qb6+  12. Kh1 Bc8  13. Qf3 bxa4  14. Rxa4 Be6  15. Bxe6 fxe6  16. fxe5 dxe5
17. Na2 Nbd7  18. Qg3 0-0  19. Bxe5 Nxe5  20. Qxe5 c5  21. Nf4 Ng4  22. Qh5 Nf6  23. Qh3 Nh7
24. g3 e5  25. Nd5 Rxf1+  26. Qxf1 Qb7  27. Nxe7+ Qxe7  28. bxc5 Qxc5  29. Rc4 Qe3  30. Nc3 Rf8
31. Qg1 Rf2  32. Nd5 Qf3+        0-1

 

White: Mike Ware  v Black: Neville Gill   (C07 French defence Tarrasch open)
1. e4 e6  2. d4 d5  3. Nd2 c5  4. c3 cxd4  5. cxd4 dxe4  6. Nxe4 Bb4+  7. Bd2 Qxd4  8. Nc3 Nc6
9. Nf3 Qd8  10. Bb5 Nge7  11. 0-0 0-0  12. Rc1 a6  13. Ba4 b5  14. Bc2 Bb7  15. Qe2 Ng6
16. h4 Nd4  17. Nxd4 Qxd4  18. Bxg6 hxg6  19. h5 gxh5  20. a3 Bd6  21. Bg5 Qe5  22. Qxe5 Bxe5
23. Rfe1 f6  24. Be3 Rad8  25. f4 Bd4  26. Bxd4 Rxd4  27. Rxe6 Rxf4  28. Rd1 Rf7  29. Nd5 Bxd5
30. Rxd5 Rc7  31. Rxa6 Rc1+  32. Kh2 Rh4+  33. Kg3 Rg4+  34. Kf3 Rf1+  35. Ke2 Rb1  
36. Rxb5 Rxb2+  37. Rxb2 Rxg2+  38. Kf3 Rxb2  39. Ra7 Kh7  40. a4 Rb3+  41. Kg2 Ra3  
42. a5 Kh6  43. a6 g5  44. Ra8 Kg6  45. a7 Kf5  46. Kf2 h4  47. Kg2 Kg4  48. Rf8 Rxa7  
49. Rxf6 Ra2+  50. Kh1 Kg3  51. Rf1 g4  52. Rg1+ Kf3  53. Rf1+ Rf2  54. Rg1 G3  55. Rb1 Re2
 56. Rf1+ Ke3  57. Rg1 Rh2#           0-1

 


Round 3 - 7th November 2001.

Sacrifice of knight to gods of no avail

Neville Gill and Alan Robertson remain as joint leaders after the third round of the Monarch trophy chess tournament.

Alan had a bye and Neville defeated Frank Maher in a game where Frank gifted him a pawn on move six. Undeterred, he continued with an attack against Neville's king. This turned out to be of no avail even after sacrificing a knight to propitiate the gods. After that it was only a short time before Neville chalked up his third successive win.

A Tarrasch variation French defence resulted in a blocked position on the queen side in Jonathan Waugh's game against John Griffin, black.  On the other side of the board however the situation was very different with Jonathan building up a steady attack, which tore John's defences to shreds and allowed mate on move 25.  This leaves Jonathan half a point behind the joint leaders.

Having lost to Neville Gill with the Colle system in round one Richard Sargent persevered with it, this time to greater effect against Mike Ware. Richard gained a pawn early on and after the exchange of minor pieces Mike had to face the endgame with an inferior pawn structure. Richard gradually rounded up the stray pawns and won in a workmanlike fashion.

Scores of all games in the competition follow this report.  Visitors comments on the positions featured and on any other aspects of the games are welcome.            TROMPOWSKI

  

Crosstable after round 3

Pos Player Grade Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Total
1= Gill, Neville 192 6+ Bye+ 5+ 3
2= Robertson, Alan 108 7+ 4+ Bye+ 3
3 Waugh, Jonathan 143 5+ 7= 4+
4= Griffin, John 105 Bye+ 2- 3- 1
5= Maher, Frank 127 3- 6+ 1- 1
6= Sargent, Richard 110 1- 5- 7+ 1
7 Ware, Mike 114 2- 3= 6- ½
8 Bye - 4- 1- 2- 0

  

Round 3 results

Jonathan Waugh (1½) 1-0 John Griffin (1)
Richard Sargent (0) 1-0