Internet Store and Ecommerce Solution Provider - Free Web Site - Free Web Space and Site Hosting - Web Hosting - High Speed Internet
Search the Web

Manx Championships 2002

 

    Last revised: 26 January, 2003.    

Isle of Man Chess Association

Southern Chess Club

   

  

Visitor Number                 Visitor Number

http://www.fxweb.com/tracker/index.shtml

 

 MANX  CHAMPIONSHIPS 2000/2001 ARCHIVES


MANX  CHAMPIONSHIPS 2001/2002

(Analysis by Alan Ormsby using Fritz 7.0, Newspaper reports by TROMPOWSKI)

Round 1    Round 2    Round 3    Round 4    Round 5    Round 6    Round 7

Patrick Taylor presents Neville Gill with the trophy

Neville Gill receives the Manx Championship Patrick Taylor Cup from Patrick Taylor, Managing Director of Monarch Assurance Plc.

 

Neville retains title after John runs out of time in the Monarch Assurance Manx Chess Championship final round

Round 7

Wednesday 6th March 2002 - Neville Gill retained the Isle of Man chess championship when he drew his final round game with John CostelloAlan Ormsby was the only other person who could have caught Neville and he was surprisingly beaten by back marker John Griffin.  The latter had the remarkable total score of three wins all against players who finished higher than him.  So Neville Gill's name will now be inscribed on the Patrick Taylor cup for the second time in its two years' existence.  How many more in the years ahead?

Final scores: N Gill 5½; A Ormsby & J Costello 4½ each; J Waugh 4; M Ware 3½; J Griffin 3; F Maher 2; A Robertson 1.

 

The crunch game was that between Alan Ormsby and John Griffin.  For the first time in serious competition play Alan deserted e4 as his opening move and found himself in a queen's gambit, Tarrasch defence.  He had a slight advantage from the opening but failed to capitalise on John's isolated queen's pawn.  Following this, Alan seemed to become lethargic, gradually losing the initiative to John who outplayed him to win in 29 moves.

White: Alan Ormsby v Black: John Griffin
1.Nf3 e6  2.d4 d5  3.c4 c5  4.e3 f6?!  5.cxd5 exd5  6.dxc5 Bxc5  7.Nc3 Ne7  8.Be2 Nbc6  9.0-0 0-0  10.a3 a6  11.b4 Bd6  12.Bb2 Be6  13.Rc1 Ne5!?  14.Nd4 Bf7  15.b5 Nc4  16.Bxc4 dxc4  17.Qg4 Qc8!  18.Qe2?! [better Qf3] Nf5  19.Nxf5?! [better Nf3] Qxf5  20.Rfd1 Rfd8  21.e4? Qe5!  22.g3 axb5  23.f4? Qe8  24.Nd5? Bc5+  25.Kf1 Rxd5! [Black finds the simplest way to win]  26.Rxd5 Bxd5  27.exd5 Qxe2+  28.Kxe2 Bxa3  29.Ra1?? [The game was already over before this dreadful move!]Re8+        0-1

 

In the meantime, John Costello and Neville Gill were still fairly level on the board, but John had only 2 minutes left for 22 moves - an impossible situation for him.  When Neville heard that Alan Ormsby had lost, he immediately offered John a draw, as he now needed only half a point to win the championship.  His offer was accepted even quicker than immediately.

White: John Costello v Black: Neville Gill
1.d4 Nf6  2.c4 e6  3.Nc3 Bb4  4.Nf3 c5  5.e3 0-0  6.Be2 d5  7.0-0 Nc6  8.cxd5 exd5  9.dxc5 Bxc5  10.a3 a6  11.b4 Ba7  12.Qc2 Be6  13.Bb2 Rc8  14.Bd3 Qe7  15.Rac1 Rfd8  16.Qe2 Bg4  17.Nd1? Ne4  18.h3 Bh5  19.g4 Bg6  20.Re1 h5  21.Kh1 hxg4  22.hxg4 Rd6  23.Ne5 Re8  24.Nxc6 bxc6  25.Kg2 f5  26.Rg1 Draw agreed after Ormsby lost his game, making Neville Gill the 2002 Manx Chess Champion.     ½-½

 

After that, the results of the remaining games were somewhat academic, but for the record Jonathan Waugh put paid to Alan Robertson's Colle system,

White: Alan Robertson v Black: Jonathan Waugh
1.d4 Nf6  2.Nf3 g6  3.c3 Bg7  4.Nbd2 d5  5.e3 0-0  6.Bd3 Nbd7  7.0-0 Re8  8.Re1 e5  9.dxe5 Nxe5  10.Nxe5 Rxe5  11.Nf3 Re8  12.Qc2 Qe7  13.Bd2 a6  14.a4 Bg4  15.b4 Bxf3  16.gxf3 Rad8  17.Rab1 c6  18.Kh1 Nh5?!  19.Rg1 Qh4  20.Rg2 Be5  21.f4 Bg7  22.Qd1 Nf6  23.f3 Nh5  24.Qg1 Qe7  25.f5 Kh8  26.Re1 Qd6  27.fxg6 hxg6  28.Rg4 Qf6  29.Rf1 Rg8  30.Qf2 Bh6  31.Rfg1 Rg7  32.f4 Rdg8  33.Be2 Rh7  34.R4g2 Ng7  35.Bg4 Nf5  36.Re1 Re8  37.Qf1 Nd6  38.Bf3 Ne4  39.Bxe4 Rxe4  40.Qf3 Qf5  41.Rg4 Bg7  42.Re2 Rc4  43.Rg5 Qe4  44.Qxe4 Rxe4  45.Be1 Rc4  46.Rc2 Bf6  47.Rg4 Kg7  48.Kg2 Rh8  49.Kf3 a5!?  50.Rgg2? Ra8  51.b5? Rxa4  52.bxc6 bxc6  53.Rb2 Ra7  54.Rgc2 Rc4  55.Ke2 Be7  56.Ra2 Bc5  57.Kf3 a4  58.Re2 a3  59.e4 Rxe4  60.Rxe4 dxe4+  61.Kxe4 Re7+    0-1

 

and Mike Ware was successful in an irregular queen's gambit against Frank Maher.

White: Mike Ware v Black: Frank Maher
1.Nf3 h6!?/?!  2.d4 d5  3.c4 Bf5  4.cxd5 Bxb1?  5.Qa4+! c6  6.dxc6 Nxc6  7.Rxb1 Qa5+? [Black, a pawn down for nothing, surely should keep the Queens on]  8.Qxa5 Nxa5  9.e3 Nf6  10.Bb5+ Nc6  11.Bxc6+ bxc6  12.Bd2 e6  13.0-0?! [e2 is a better square for the King] Nd5?! [better Ne4]  14.Ba5 c5  15.Rbc1 Rb8?  16.b3?! Rb5  17.Be1?! Be7  18.dxc5 0-0 19.b4 Rfb8 20.Rc4 Nf6  21.Nd4 R5b7  22.Nc6 Rc8  23.Nxe7+ Rxe7  24.Bc3 Nd5  25.Be5 Rb7  26.a3 a5? [but Black is lost anyway]  27.bxa5 f6  28.Bd6 Rb5  29.e4 Nc7  30.Ra4 Na6  31.h3 Kf7  32.Rc1 Rc6  33.Kh2 Ke8  34.Rc3 Kf7  35.e5 f5  36.g4 g6  37.gxf5 gxf5  38.Rh4 Kg6  39.Rg3+ Kh7  40.Bf8    1-0

 

TROMPOWSKI

 

____________________________________________________________________

Round 6  

(Analysis by Alan Ormsby using Fritz 7.0, Newspaper reports by TROMPOWSKI)

All to play for in the Monarch Assurance Manx Chess Championship final round.

Thursday 28th February - The sixth round of  the Manx Chess championship saw Mike Ware holding the current champion Neville Gill to a draw.  John Costello who was just a half point in arrears failed to capitalise on his opportunity when he lost to John Griffin and his second place was taken by Alan Ormsby who beat Jonathan Waugh in 14 moves. 

Neville Gill is leading by half a point going into this week's final round where he plays John Costello while Alan Ormsby meets John Griffin.  Minor place pairings are Mike Ware against Frank Maher and Jonathan Waugh faces Alan Robertson.  Anything can happen.

Scores are:- N Gill 5; A Ormsby 4½; J Costello 4; J Waugh 3; M Ware 2½; J Griffin & F Maher 2 each; A Robertson 1.

 

Jonathan steered Alan's Caro Kann defence into a sharp variation, which was really leading with his chin, as Alan is the chief exponent of this defence on the island.  True to form Alan sprung an attack on Jonathan's king which was stuck in the middle of the board.  When the dust had settled Alan was two pawns to the good entering the endgame and his opponent threw in the towel.

White: Jonathan Waugh v Black: Alan Ormsby
1.e4 c6  2.d4 d5  3.exd5 cxd5  4.c4 Nf6  5.Nc3 Nc6  6.Nf3 Bg4  7.Qb3? [an unfortunate inaccuracy. White must play cxd5 first] Bxf3  8.gxf3 Nxd4  9.Qa4+ Qd7  10.Nb5? Nxf3+  11.Ke2 Nd4+  12.Ke1 Qe6+  13.Be3 Nxb5  14.cxb5 Qe4 forcing the exchange of queens.  Although white has some compensation for the 2 pawns deficit, it is a winning position for black.    0-1

 

Mike Ware's Nimzo Indian defence kept Neville Gill at bay though initially Neville appeared to have the edge.  He then seemed to drift into a queen and pawns ending without having made any middle game headway.  These endings are notoriously difficult for either side to win and so it proved.

White: Neville Gill v Black: Mike Ware
1.d4 Nf6  2.c4 e6  3.Nc3 Bb4  4.Qc2 c5  5.dxc5 Bxc5  6.Nf3 Nc6  7.Bg5 Nd4  8.Nxd4 Bxd4  9.e3 Qa5  10.exd4 Qxg5  11.g3 0-0  12.Bg2 Rb8  13.0-0 a6  14.b4 d6  15.c5 d5  16.f4 Qh6  17.Bf3 Qh3  18.a4 Ng4  19.Bxg4 Qxg4  20.b5 Bd7  21.Qd3 h5?! [going for maximum activity but Ra8 is objectively stronger]  22.h4?! [better 22.bxa6 bxa6  23.Qxa6] Rfd8  23.Rf2 Kf8?!  24.Rb2 e5? [Again, objectively bad but black faced a difficult position anyway]  25.fxe5 Bf5  26.Qe3 axb5  27.axb5 Ra8  28.Rba2 Rxa2  29.Rxa2 Be4  30.Qg5 [better Ra7] Qd7  31.Ra7 Rb8  32.c6 Qc7  33.Nxe4 dxe4  34.Rxb7 Rxb7  35.cxb7 Qb6  36.Qe3?! [36.e6! wins for white] Qxb7  37.Qa3+ Kg8  38.Qc5 Qa8  39.d5? Qa1+  40.Kg2 Qxe5  41.Kf2 Qf5+  42.Ke1 Qe5  43.Kf2 Qf5+  44.Ke1 Qe5  45.Kf2     ½-½

 

More drifting occurred in John Costello's centre counter game against John Griffin.  Both castled long and Griffin seized a poisoned pawn without any riposte from Costello who is usually quite an aggressive player.  Griffin added another pawn to his hoard which he later gave back to force the exchange of queens.  This left him with a distant passed pawn against Costello's two half passed pawns in the centre of the board and Griffin ran out an easy winner.

White: John Griffin v Black: John Costello
1.e4 d5  2.exd5 Qxd5  3.Nc3 Qa5  4.Bc4 Nf6  5.d3 Bg4  6.Nf3 c6  7.Bd2 Qc7  8.Qe2 e6  9.h3 Bxf3  10.Qxf3 Bd6  11.Ne4 Nxe4  12.Qxe4 Nd7  13.Qg4 0-0-0!?  14.Qxg7 Nb6?! [and black will struggle to win back the pawn, better was Ne5!]  15.0-0-0 Be5  16.Qg4 Rhg8  17.Qe4?! [better Qf3] Nxc4  18.dxc4 Rd4  19.Qe3?! [19.Qf3 Rxc4=] Rgd8 [19......Rxg2  20.Rhe1 Bf6=]  20.g3 c5  21.Bc3 Rxd1+  22.Rxd1 Rxd1+  23.Kxd1 Qd6+  24.Ke2 Bd4? [better 24......Bxc3  25.Qxc3 e5]  25.Bxd4 cxd4  26.Qg5 f5  27.Qg8+ Kc7  28.Qxh7+ Kb6  29.Qh8 Kc5  30.Qc8+ Kb6  31.c5+! Qxc5  32.Qxc5+ Kxc5  33.h4 Kd6  34.Kf3 e5  35.g4 e4+  36.Kf4 d3  37.cxd3 exd3  38.Ke3 fxg4  39.Kxd3 Ke5  40.Ke3 Kf5  41.b4 a6  42.a4 b6  43.Kd4 Kf4  44.Kd5 kf3  45.h5 Kxf2  46.h6 g3  47.h7 g2  48.h8Q g1Q  49.Qd4+     1-0

 

The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune did their worst for Alan Robertson in his tussle with Frank Maher.  Alan had so strong an attack going that Frank, who was in bad time trouble, was one move away from resigning when Alan slipped while trying to keep the pressure up by moving fast and lost a rook and the game.

White: Frank Maher v Black: Alan Robertson
1.c4 Nf6  2.g3 d6  3.Bg2 g6  4.d4 Bg7  5.Nc3 c6  6.e4 0-0  7.Nge2 Qc7  8.0-0 Nbd7  9.Bd2 Nb6  10.b3 Bd7  11.Rc1 Rad8  12.Qc2 Qc8  13.Rfe1 Bh3  14.Bh1 e5  15.d5 Nh5  16.Qd3 f5  17.Bg5 Bf6  18.Bxf6 Rxf6?! [better Nxf6]  19.exf5 gxf5? [better Bxf5]  20.f3? [better 20.dxc6 bxc6  21.Qf3] Qd7  21.Nd1 e4  22.fxe4 fxe4  23.Bxe4 Qf7  24.Nd4 Rf8  25.Ne3 Nd7? [better c5]  26.dxc6 bxc6  27.Nxc6? [better Bxc6] Nc5!  28.Qd4 Nxe4  29.Qxe4 Re6  30.Qh4 Qf2+  31.Kh1 Qf3+?? [31.....Bg2+  32.Nxg2 Rxe1+  33.Rxe1 Qf1+  34.Rxf1 Rxf1#]  32.Kg1 Bg2??  33.Qg4+ Qxg4  34.Nxg4 Bxc6?? [34.....Rxe1+  35.Rxe1 Bxc6  36.Re7]  35.Rxe6 Bd7  36.Re4 Bf5  37.Nh6+ Kg7  38.Nxf5+ Rxf5  39.Rd4       1-0

 

TROMPOWSKI

 

____________________________________________________________________

Round 5 

(Analysis by Alan Ormsby using Fritz 7.0, Newspaper reports by TROMPOWSKI)

Thursday 21st February - Neville Gill won his postponed third round game against Jonathan Waugh in the Monarch Assurance Manx Chess championship and followed it up with a further win this week over Alan Robertson in the fifth round.  His co-leader, John Costello, lost half a point to Mike Ware so Neville leads by this same narrowest of margins.

Scores after five rounds out of seven:- N Gill 4½; J Costello 4; A Ormsby 3½; J Waugh 3; M Ware 2; J Griffin, F Maher, A Robertson 1 each.

  

Round 3 postponed game

White: Jonathan Waugh v Black: Neville Gill - Round 3 postponed game  (Notes by Neville Gill)
1.e4 e5  2.Nf3 Nc6  3.Bb5 a6  4.Ba4 d6  5.Bxc6+ bxc6  6.d4 f6  7.0-0 Ne7  8.Nc3 Ng6  9.Be3 Be7  10.h3 0-0  11.Qd2 Be6  12.Rad1 Qd7  13.dxe5 fxe5  14.Ng5 Bxg5  15.Bxg5 Nf4  16.Bxf4 Rxf4  17.f3 Raf8  18.Kh2 R8f6  19.Ne2 Rh4  20.Ng1 Rfh6  21.g4 Bxg4?(a)  22.fxg4 Qxg4  23.Qg2 Qe6?(b)  24.Rd3 Rg6  25.Rg3? Rxg3  26.Kxg3 Qg6+  27.Kh2 Qxg2+  28.Kxg2 Rxe4(c)  29.Rf3 Ra4  30.a3 Rc4  31.Rc3?(d) Rxc3  32.bxc3 Kf7  33.Kf3 Ke6  34.Ke4 d5+  35.Ke3 Kf5  36.Kf3 c5  37.Ne2 e4+  38.Ke3 Ke5  39.Ng3 d4+  40.Ke2 g6  41.Kf2 h5  42.Nf1 Kf4  43.Kg2 g5  44.Ng3 h4  45.Nf1 e3 [g4! wins easily]  46.Nh2 Ke4  47.Nf3 d3  48.Nxg5+? [the last move before the time control. How often does it lose a game! 48. cxd3+ Kxd3  49. Nxg5 and black can lose if he tries too hard to win]  48.......Kf5  49.cxd3 Kxg5  50.Kf3 e2  51.Kxe2 Kf4  52.a4 a5  53.Kf2 c4! is the key move I had seen much earlier but back on move 45 I should have seen 48. cxd3+ as well.  54.dxc4 c5  55.Ke2 Kg3  56.Ke3 Kxh3  57.Kf3 Kh2  58.Kf2 h3  59.Kf1 Kg3  60.Kg1 Kf3  61.Kh2 Ke3  62.Kxh3 Kd3  63.Kg3 Kxc4  64.Kf3 Kxc3  65.Ke3 c4       0-1
(a) an unjustified sacrifice  21......Rg6 followed by h5 was better
(b) even worse.  23.......Qxg2+!  24. Kxg2 Rxe4 =
(c) Black should not have been allowed to get a third pawn for the piece.
(d) Exchanging Rooks was the last thing white should have done.  3 pawns are generally better 
     than a lone knight.   31. c3!

 

Round 5 games

Being a piece up against Mike Ware, John Costello looked all set to win the game when, after three and a half hours play he lost the piece back and was fortunate to be offered a draw by Mike who was two pawns to the good.  However, both players had less than three minutes to make ten moves and Mike decided to take the cautious route of settling for a draw though he had what must have been a winning position.

White: Mike Ware v Black: John Costello         
1.Nf3 d5  2.d4 Nf6  3.Bg5 e6  4.Nbd2 Be7  5.e3 0-0  6.Bd3 Nbd7  7.0-0 c5  8.c4!? cxd4  9.Nxd4 h6  10.Bh4 Ne5  11.Be2 Nc6  12.N4f3 d4!?  13.Qb3 e5  14.Rfd1 Nd7  15.Bxe7 Qxe7  16.Ne4 Kh8  17.Rac1 f5  18.Ng3 Nc5  19.Qa3 d3  20.Bf1 a5  21.Nh4 Kh7  22.Bxd3? e4  23.Be2 Nb4  24.Nf3 exf3  25.Bxf3 Bd7 White only has two pawns for the piece but Black's time trouble gives him hope.  26.Rd2 Bc6  27.Bd5 Ne4  28.Nxe4 fxe4  29.Bxc6 bxc6  30.b3 Qf6  31.Rf1 Nd3  32.Qa4 Qc3  33.Rdd1 Rf6?!(a)  34.c5 Raf8?? [Nxf2 again wins easily]  35.Qxe4+ [winning for white] Kh8  36.Qxd3 Qxc5  37.Rde1 Qa3  38.Qc2 Qb4  39.h3 Qh4(b)  and Mike generously offered a draw in mutual time trouble       ½-½
(a) With more time available Black would probably have seen this tactical blow 33......Nxf2!
34. Rxf2 Qxe3 and white can resign e.g. 35 Rdf1 Rxf2  36. Rf8
(b) Better is 39......Rxf2  40. Qxf2 Rxf2  41. Kxf2 when white, with best play should prevail in
      the end.

 

Neville Gill disposed of Alan Robertson's Sicilian defence rather easily when Alan took a very non-aggressive line as white.  This led to his forces being poorly placed and the game came to an untimely end when he lost a piece on his twenty first move.
White: Alan Robertson v Black: Neville Gill
1.Nf3 c5  2.e4 e6  3.Nc3 Nc6  4.d3 [4. d4  The only hope of retaining the advantage of the white pieces] 4.......Nf6  5.Bg5 Be7  6.g3 h6  7.Bf4 d5! Black grabs the initiative already.  8.exd5 exd5 9.Bg2 0-0  10.0-0 d4  11.Ne4 Nd5  12.Bc1 f5  13.Ned2 Be6 [13......f4 is a good alternative] 14.Nc4 Bf6  15.Re1 Re8  16.a4 Qc7?(a)  17.Bd2? Rad8  18.Qc1 Kh7  19.Re2 g5  20.Qe1 Bf7  21.Nfe5?? Nxe5  22.Bxd5 Bxd5  23.Nxe5 Rxe5  24.Rxe5 Qxe5  25.Qf1 Bc6  26.Re1 Qd5   0-1

(a) Surprisingly, this is a mistake . . . . which white fails to spot! 17.Rxe6 Rxe6  18.Nxd4 Bxd4  (18......cxd4  19.Bxd5 Qd7  20.Bxe6+ Nxe6  21.Be3;  18......cxd4  19.Bxd5 Qd7  20.Qf3 Rae8  21.Bd2}  19.Bxd5 Qd7  20.Qf3 Rd8  21.Bxe6+ Qxe6  22.Be3.

 

The Pirc defence of Frank Maher proved no good against Alan Ormsby's accurate play and Alan ran out the winner by piling up a number of small but significant advantages eventually giving mate on move 38.
White: Alan Ormsby v Black: Frank Maher     
1.e4 d6  2.d4 Nf6  3.Nc3 g6  4.Be3 bg7  5.f3 0-0?  6.Qd2 Nbd7  7.0-0-0 e5?! [7.....c6 is better]  8.d5 b6?! 9.h4 h5  10.Bg5 Nc5  11.b4 Nb7  12.Ba6 Qd7  13.Nge2 Nh7??  14.Bh6? [Bb5 wins the game] c5? [better 14......Nf6]  15.dxc6(e.p.) Qxc6  16.Bxg7 Kxg7  17.Bxb7 Bxb7  18.Qxd6 Qxd6  19.Rxd6 Nf6  20.Rhd1 Rac8  21.a3 Bc6  22.Kb2 Rfe8  23.Ng3 Re7  24.Nf1 Bd7  25.Ne3 Be6  26.Rd8 Rc6  27.Ncd5 Rb7  28.Nxf6 Kxf6  29.Nd5+ Bxd5  30.R8xd5 Ke6  31.R1d3 Rbc7  32.c3 Rc4  33.Rd6+ Ke7  34.R6d5 Ke6  35.Kb3! setting a trap ... Kf6  36.Rd6+ Ke7 ..which Black falls into as an exchange of the rooks is now forced and white should be able to create a passed pawn and infiltrate with the King;  37.Rd7+! Ke6??  38.R3d6#     1-0

 

Jonathan Waugh came storming back after his loss to Neville and made short work of John Griffin's French defence.  Jonathan established a strong knight outpost which led to winning the exchange.  This was shortly followed by further material gain which left his opponent defenceless.
White: Jonathan Waugh v Black: John Griffin
1.e4 e6  2d4 d5  3.Nd2 Bd7  4.e5 c5  5.c3 Nc6  6.Ne2 cxd4  7.cxd4 f6  8.exf6 Nxf6  9.Nf3 Qb6  10.Nc3 Rc8  11.Be2 Bb4  12.0-0 0-0  13.a3 Qa5  14.Bd2 Be7  15.b4 Qb6  16.Na4 Qc7  17.Nc5 Rcd8?!  18.Rc1 Bc8  19.b5! Nxd4  20.Nxe6 Nxe2+?!  21.Qxe2 Qd6  22.Nxf8 Bxf8  23.Bb4 Qf4  24.Rxc8! and white wins       1-0

 

TROMPOWSKI

 

____________________________________________________________________

Round 4 

(Analysis by Alan Ormsby using Fritz 7.0, Newspaper reports by TROMPOWSKI)

Thursday 7th February 2002 - John Costello continued to forge ahead in the  Monarch Assurance Manx Chess championship with a sound win against Alan Robertson while Neville Gill, the reigning champion, was held to a draw by Alan Ormsby.  Neville is now a full point behind John though he has a postponed game in hand.

With Neville Gill and Jonathan Waugh both having a game in hand the scores after four rounds are:- J Costello 3½; N Gill, A Ormsby 2½ each; J Waugh 2; M Ware 1½; J Griffin, F Maher, A Robertson 1 each.

From John Costello's queen's gambit Alan Robertson, playing black, launched into an early exuberant though premature attack which weakened his own position.  He was repulsed by solid play by John who next mounted his attack which demolished Alan's game.

White: John Costello v Black:  Alan Robertson
1. d4 d5  2. c4 e6  3. Nc3 Nf6  4. Bg5 Be7  5. e3 Nbd7  6. Nf3 h6  7. Bh4 0-0  8. Qc2 c6
9. cxd5 exd5  10. Bd3 Re8  11. 0-0 Nf8  12. h3 Be6  13. Ne2 g5?!  14. Bg3 Nh5  15. Be5 Ng7
16. Bxg7!? Kxg7  17. Ng3 Kg8  18. Nf5 Bxf5  19. Bxf5 Bd6  20. Nh2 Bxh2+?!  21. Kxh2 Qd6+
22. g3 Ne6  23. Kg2 Re7  24. Rh1 Rae8  25. h4 Kg7  26. Bxe6! Rxe6  27. hxg5 hxg5  28. Qh7+ Kf8
29. Qf5 Rg6  30. Rh8+ Ke7? [the losing move]  31. Rxe8+ Kxe8  32. Qc8+ Qd8  33. Qxb7 a5
34. Rh1 Qd6  35. Rh8+       1-0

 

In the meantime Alan Ormsby's Slav defence was met by Neville Gill with a seventh move first played 70 years ago and rarely seen since.  After this game it may not be seen again until the next century as Neville failed to get any grip on the game with it.  In fact he considered himself fortunate when Alan offered a draw in a position probably more favourable to black and had no hesitation in accepting.

White: Neville Gill v Black: Alan Ormsby
1. d4 Nf6  2. Nf3 c6  3. c4 d5  4. e3 Bf5  5. cxd5 cxd5  6. Qb3 Qc7  7. Na3 e6  8. Bd2 Be7
9. Rc1 Nc6  10. Bb5 0-0  11. 0-0?! [better Ne5] Rfc8!  12. Qa4 Qb6  13. Bxc6 bxc6  14. b3 Bd3
Draw offered and accepted          ½-½

 

Jonathan Waugh had an easy win over Frank Maher when Frank miscalculated in a tactical encounter and lost a piece.

White:  Frank Maher  v Black: Jonathan Waugh    
1. c4 e5  2. g3 Nc6  3. Bg2 g6  4. b3 Bg7  5. Bb2 d6  6. e4?! [better Nc3] Nf6  7. Ne2 Be6
8. d4 exd4  9. Nxd4 Nxd4  10. Bxd4 Qd7  11. Qf3?! [better 0-0] Bg4  12. Qc3 Qe7  13. f3? c5!
14. Bxc5 dxc5  15. Qe3??[losing a piece] Bd7  16. Nc3 0-0 17. Rd1 Bc6  18. Ne2 Rad8
19. 0-0 b6  20. Kh1 Rxd1  21 Rxd1 Rd8  22. Rxd8+ Qxd8  23. Nc3 Qd4    0-1

 

From a four knights game, John Griffin got off the mark against Mike Ware.  After giving up a pawn early on, John won two knights for a rook and was eventually left with both his bishops which dominated the board.  This resulted in delivering mate in 39 moves.

White: John Griffin v Black: Mike Ware     
1. e4 e5  2. Nf3 Nc6  3. Nc3 Nf6  4. Bc4 Bc5  5. a3 0-0  6. 0-0 d6  7. Nd5 Nxe4  8. b4? Bb6?(a)
9. Nxb6?! [better d3] axb6  10. Re1 Nf6  11. d4 e4  12. Ng5?! d5  13. Ba2 h6  14. Nh3 Qd6?
15. Bf4 Qd8?!  16. c3 Ne7  17. f3 Bxh3  18. gxh3 exf3?!  19. Qxf3 c6?[Rxa3]  20. Re2 Ng6
 21. Rg2 Ne4?![Nh4 wins]  22. Rxg6! fxg6  23. Qxe4 Rf5?  24. Rf1?? Qh4?  25. Qe6+ Kh7
 26. Bb1 Rf6  27. Qe3 Raf8  28. Qg3 Qh5??(b)  29. Bd3 Kh8?!  30. Be5 Rxf1+  31. Bxf1 Qf5?
32. Bd3 Qf7?  33. Bd6 Ra8  34. Bxg6 Qg8  35. b5 Ra5  36. Qe3 Ra8  37. Be5 and the game is over
37......Qd8  38. Qxh6+ Kg8  39. Qxg7#
(a) 8......Bxf2+  9. Rxf2 Nxf2  10. Kxf2 e4 and analysis shows that black wins in all variations
(b) and for the first time in the game, white obtains a clear advantage.

TROMPOWSKI

 

____________________________________________________________________

Round 3 

(Analysis by Alan Ormsby using Fritz 7.0, Newspaper reports by TROMPOWSKI)

Thursday 31st January 2002 - The Third round of the Monarch Assurance Manx Chess championship saw the game between Neville Gill, the holder, and Jonathan Waugh postponed due to illness.  Neville's co-leader on full points, Alan Ormsby, had the opportunity to move into sole leadership but he was forestalled by John Costello who was lying half a point in arrears.

With Gill and Waugh having a game in hand the leading scores after three rounds out of seven are:- J Costello 2½; N Gill & A Ormsby 2 each; M Ware 1½; J Waugh, F Maher & A Robertson 1 each.

 

Following John Costello's centre counter game in which black, in some variations, has to be careful to leave a clear flight path for his queen, Alan Ormsby on white, left a bishop without a flight square and had to give it up for two pawns.  After this Alan could only fight a rearguard action and resigned after 33 moves.

White: Alan Ormsby v Black: John Costello         
1. e4 d5  2. exd5 Qxd5  3. Nf3 Bg4  4. Be2 e5?!  5. 0-0 Nc6  6. Nc3 Qd7  7. d3?(a) 0-0-0
8. a3 f5  9. Be3 Nf6  10. b4 Qe8  11. Nd2 Nd4  12. Bxg4 Nxg4  13. h3 Nf6  14. Rc1 b6?! [played
after 23 mins thought]  15. Ne2?? [played after 23 seconds thought, much better was Bxd4] 
15...... Nxe2+  16. Qxe2 f4  17. Bxf4 exf4  18. Qf3 Kb8  19. Rfe1 Qd7  20. Qxf4 Bd6 [white only has
two pawns for the piece but both players were now short of time]  21. Qc4 Rhe8  22. Red1 Re7
23. Nf3 Rde8  24. Nd4 Kb7  25. Rb1 Be5  26. Nb3 Qd5!  27. Qh4 Bc328. Kf1 Re2  29. Kg1 Rxc2
30. Nc5+ Kc8(b)  31. Na6 Bd4  32. Rf1 Ree2  33. Kh1 Rxf2       0-1
(a) 7. Nxe5 was better
(b) 30..... bxc5  31. bxc5+ Ka8  32. Qa4 Rxf2  33. Kxf2 Re2+  34. Kxe2 Qxg2+  35. Ke3 Nd5#

 

From an irregular opening Alan Robertson secured a superior position against Mike Ware and then gave up two pawns to launch a foray against Mike's king.  When this proved inconclusive Mike was left with beautiful open files down which he exploded with both rooks, queen and bishop.  Alan was unceremoniously blown out of the water.

White: Alan Robertson v Black: Mike Ware     
1. d4 e6  2. Nf3 Bb4+?!  3. Nbd2 Nf6  4. a3 Ba5  5. b4 Bb6  6. Bb2 a5  7. e4 Qe7?  8. b5?! 0-0
9. Be2 d6  10. a4 Bd7  11. 0-0 c6  12. Nc4! Bd8  13. Bd3? cxb5  14. axb5 Bxb5  15. Ba3?! Bxc4
16. Bxc4 Qc7? [better Nxc4]  17. Qd3 Be7  18. Bb3 Nc6  19. c3 Rfb8  20. Bc2 e5?!  21. d5 Na7
22. Rfb1 b5  23. Bc1 h6  24. Nh4 Nxd5?!  25. exd5 Bxh4  26. Qh7+ Kf8  27. Qh8+ Ke7
28. Qxg7 Rg8  29. Qxh6 Bf6  30. Qh3 Rh8  31. Qf3 a4  32. Ba3 Rac8  33. Bb4 Rh4  34. Be4 Rch8
35. h3 Nc8  36. Qd3 Qb6?![better Nb6]  37. Ra2 Na7  38. Rab2 Qd8  39. Bf5 Rc4  40. Qe3 Qc7
41. Bd3 Rch4  42. Qe2 Qd7  43. Qf1[better Qf3] Rg8  44. Kh2 Rgh8  45. c4? e4 46. Re2 Be5+
47 g3?? Rxh3+  48. Qxh3 Qxh3+  49. Kg1 Qh1#            0-1

 

John Griffin's play as black against Frank Maher's English opening was perhaps designed to confuse his opponent but only succeeded in diminishing his own position.  Frank achieved a virtually ideal centre and harassed John's king to the middle of the board where it was despatched in short order.

White: Frank Maher v Black: John Griffin      (English opening)
1. c4 Nf6  2. g3 g6  3. b3 d6  4. Bb2 Bg7  5. Bg2 Nc6  6. Nc3 Ne5?  7. d4 Neg4  8. h3 Nh6
9. Nf3 c6  10. 0-0 Qb6?  11. e4 Nd7 [sensible development by white has left him with a clear
advantage]  12. Re1 f5?  13. Na4 Qc7  14. Ng5 Nb6  15. Nc3 Nf7?  16. Nxf7 Kxf7  17. exf5 e6??
18. fxg6+ hxg6  19. Qf3+ Ke7  20. Re2 d5  21. cxd5 Nxd5  22. Nxd5+ cxd5  23. Qxd5 Rh5
24 Qe4 Kf7  25. Rc1 Qb6  26. Rec2 e5?  27. Rc7+ [white doesn't even need to waste time taking
the bishop!] Ke6  28. Qxg6+ Bf6  29. d5+ Kd6  30. Qxf6+    1-0    A very pleasing final position
for white but perhaps the most striking features are the black queen's rook and bishop still
stuck on their original squares.

TROMPOWSKI

 

____________________________________________________________________

Round 2 

(Analysis by Alan Ormsby using Fritz 7.0, Newspaper reports by TROMPOWSKI)

Thursday 17th January 2002 - Reigning champion Neville Gill continued his winning ways in the second round of the Monarch Assurance Manx Chess Championship when he scored an easy win over Frank Maher and is joint leader with Alan Ormsby who beat Mike Ware.  

Leading Scores: N Gill & A Ormsby 2, J Costello 1½, J Waugh & A Robertson 1.

 

Neville Gill secured a favourable attacking position against Frank Maher's Budapest defence and converted it into the win of a piece, followed by the game.

White: Neville Gill v Black: Frank Maher      (Budapest Gambit)
1. d4 Nf6  2. c4 e5  3. dxe5 Ne4?!  4. a3!? b6  5. Nd2 Bb7  6. e3 Nc5  7. Ngf3 d6  8. exd6 Bxd6
9. Be2(a) Nbd7?!(b) 10. 0-0 0-0  11. b4 Ne6  12. Bb2(c) c5  13. b5 Qc7  14. Qc2 h6  15. Ne4 Be7
16. Rad1 f5?!  17. Nc3 g5?(d)  18. Nd5 Bxd5  19. cxd5 Ng7  20. d6 Bxd6  21. Qd2 and white wins 
after 21...... Ne8  22. Qd5+ Kh7  23. Qxa8 g4  24. Qc6 Qxc6  25. bxc6 gxf3  26. cxd7 fxe2
27. dxe8Q exf1Q+  28. Kxf1 Rxe8  29. Rxd6       1-0
(a) White is quietly developing, but perhaps stronger was b4 which was eventually played on move 11.
(b) Black missed chances to play a5 stopping b4.
(c) Black is left with no compensation for the pawn
(d) Instead of moves 16 and 17, perhaps black should have brought his rooks to the central files and see
what white does.  The black King is now very exposed.

 

Alan Ormsby, on the other hand, had a long drawn out struggle with Mike Ware which went to an adjournment and over an hour's play on resumption.  Alan's favourite Caro Kann defence could have cost him dearly when on the fourth move, playing on automatic pilot, he made an error which Mike failed to spot.

White M Ware:  Black A Ormsby:  1.e4 c6  2.d4 d5  3.e5 Bf5  4.Bd3 Bg6? A bad blunder  5.Bxg6 hxg6  6. Nd2? white does not take advantage of 6.e6 which either leaves the f8 bishop entombed or the black king's pawn shield in tatters!  Later, Alan won a pawn and it was this that made all the difference 40 moves down the road.  His mobile knight against Mike's restricted bishop allowed him to force through the extra pawn to the eighth rank.

White: Mike Ware v Black: Alan Ormsby    (Caro Kann defence)
1. e4 c6  2. d4 d5  3. e5 Bf5  4. Bd3 Bg6? 5. Bxg6 hxg6  6. Nd2? e6  7. Nb3 Nd7  8. Qd3 Qc7
9. Bd2 Rc8  10. Ne2 c5  11. Nxc5 Nxc5  12. dxc5 Bxc5  13. Qb5+ Qc6  14. Qxc6+ Rxc6
15. c3 Ne7  16. Nd4?! Bxd4  17. cxd4 Kd7  18. 0-0 Rhc8  19. Bc3 Rc4  20. Rac1?! Nf5 
21. Rcd1 [Rfd1? Nxd4] b5  22. a3 Ne7  23. Bb4 Nc6  24. Bc5 a5  25. Rd3? Rb8? [Nxe5]
26. Rfd1? Nxe5  27. Rc3 Rxc3  28. bxc3 Nc4  29. Rd3 Rh8  30. h3 a4  31. Kh2 Ke8  32. Rd1 Kd7
33. Rd3 Rh4  34. g4 Rh8  35 Kg3 g5  36. Rd1 g6  37. Rb1 Kc6  38. Re1 Nd2  39. f3 Nc4  
40. Re2 Kd7  41. Bb4 f5  42. Kg2 Re8  43. Re1 e5  44. dxe5 Rxe5  45. Rxe5 Nxe5  46. Kg3 Ke6
47. Bc5 Nc6  48. f4 gxf4+  49. Kxf4 fxg4  50. hxg4 d4 51. cxd4 Kd5  52. Kg5 Nxd4  
53. Bb4 Nc6? [Nc2 is stronger] 54. Bc3  Adjourned, sealed move 54.......Ne5  55. Bb2 Ke4
56. Kh4? Nc4 and there is no way back for white  57. Bc1 Kd3  58. Kg5 Kc2  59. Kxg6 Kxc1
60. g5 b4  61. Kf5 b3     0-1

 

John Costello was held to a draw by Jonathan Waugh who played his faithful King's Indian defence.  First the position on the queen's wing became blocked after John had castled long.  His subsequent pawn advance against Jonathan's king in turn also locked up the king's side and a draw was agreed when neither side could make any headway.  Jonathan's game in round one against Mike Ware ended in similar blocked circumstances leaving him with two half points.

White: John Costello v Black:  Jonathan Waugh     (Kings Indian defence)
1. d4 Nf6  2. c4 g6  3. Nc3 Bg7  4. e4 d6  5. Be2 0-0  6. Bg5 Na6  7. a3 e5  8. d5 Qe8  9. f3 h6
10. Be3 Bd7  11. Nh3 Nc5  12. Nf2 a5  13. Nd3 b6  14. Nxc5 dxc5  15. Qd2 Kh7  16. g4 Qe7
17. h4 Ne8  18. 0-0-0 Nd6  19. Rdg1 Rab8  20. Bd3 f5  21. h5 f4  22. hxg6+  Draw agreed ½-½
(Analysis using Fritz 7.0 gives a clear win for white, but no clear plan to do this - Alan Ormsby)

 

No such indecision was apparent when Alan Robertson, from an open Sicilian, won a piece from John Griffin with a neat tactic at move 30 when the game was otherwise fairly even.

White: John Griffin v Black: Alan Robertson     (Sicilian)
1. e4 c5  2. Nf3 d6  3. Bc4 e6  4. Nc3 Be7  5. d4 cxd4  6. Nxd4 Nf6  7. 0-0 0-0  8. f4 Qc7
9. Bd3?(a) a6  10. Qe2 Nbd7  11. Rf3?! Nc5  12. e5 Nxd3  13. cxd3? [better Rxd3] dxe5
14. fxe5 Ng4  15. Rh3? Qxe5  16. Qxe5 Nxe5  Black is a clear pawn up, has the bishop pair and 
can target the isolated d pawn.  17 Na4 Bd7  18. Nb6 Rad8  19. Nxd7 Rxd7  20. Bf4 Ng6
21. Be3 Rfd8  22. Nb3 Rd5?! [Why not take the pawn?]  23. d4 Bf6  24. Rc1 e5  25. dxe5 Rd1+
26. Rxd1 Rxd1+  27. Kf2 Bxe5  28. Ke2 Rd5  29. Rh5 f6  30. Nc5?? Rxc5  31. Bxc5 Nf4+
and white can safely resign!  32. Kf3 Nxh5  33. Be3 f5  34. g4 fxg4+  35. Kxg4 Nf6+  36. Kf5 Bxb2
37. Ke6 b5  38. Kd6 b4  39. Kc6 a5  40. Kb5 Nd5  41. Bb6 Nxb6  42. Kxb6 a4  43. Kb5 b3
44. axb3 axb3 [a3 is quicker] 45. Kb4 Be5         0-1
(a) the bishop is better placed on b3 so covering the a2-g8 diagonal

 

TROMPOWSKI

 

____________________________________________________________________

Round 1 

(Analysis by Alan Ormsby using Fritz 7.0, Newspaper reports by TROMPOWSKI)

Thursday 10th January 2002 - The new year has seen the start of the Manx Chess Championship sponsored for the second time by Monarch Assurance Plc.  It is being run on an all play all basis with eight competitors and the rate of play is 48 moves in two hours followed by adjournment. 

Leading scores after round one:-  N Gill, J Costello and A Ormsby 1 each,  J Waugh and M Ware ½ each.

 

For the first round no adjournments were necessary though the longest game went to 45 moves.  This was between the holder of the title, Neville Gill and John Griffin.  John accepted Neville's queen's gambit and sparks flew as early as the eleventh move when he gave up a bishop and knight for rook and pawn.  When Neville later won the exchange he was a clear piece up and won comfortably without any further drama.

White: Neville Gill v Black: John Griffin      (Queen's gambit accepted)
1. d4 d5  2. c4 dxc4  3. Nf3 Nf6  4. e3 a6  5. Bxc4 e6  6. Qe2 c5  7. dxc5 Bxc5  8. e4 b5
9. Bd3 Ng4  10. 0-0 Qb6  11. h3 Nxf2(a)  12. Rxf2 Bxf2+  13. Qxf2 Qxf2+  14. Kxf2 Nc6
15. Nc3 e5  16. Nd5 Ra7  17. Be3 Rd7  18. Rc1 Bb7  19. Bc5 f6  20. Ke3 Kf7  21. a4 bxa4
22. Nb6 Rc7(b)  23. Bd6 Re7  24. Bxe7 Nxe7  25. Rc7 Bc6  26. Bc4+ Ke8  27. Nd5 Kd8
28. Rxe7 Bxd5  29. Ra7 Bc6  30. Bd5 Bxd5  31. exd5 Re8  32. Ra8+ Kd7  33. Rxe8 Kxe8
34. Ke4 Kd7  35. Nxe5 Ke7  36. Nc4 g6  37. Nb6 Kd6  38. Nxa4 h6  39. b4 f5+  40. Kd4 g5
41. Nc5 g4  42. hxg4 fxg4  43. Ne4+ Ke7  44. Ke5 h5  45. Nf6       1-0
(a) In the exchanges that follow, white gains a bishop and knight in exchange for a rook and pawn!
(b)  The rook is trapped and has to be exchanged for a bishop, white is now a piece up!

 

Jonathan Waugh's Ruy Lopez against  Mike Ware lead to the early exchange of both bishops.  In an effort to develop a king side attack Jonathan repeatedly feinted, Mike repeatedly parried.  The position became completely locked and with all sixteen pawns on the board a draw was agreed when each could do no better than manoeuvre behind his own lines.

White: Jonathan Waugh v Black: Mike Ware      (Ruy Lopez)
1. e4 e5  2. Nf3 Nc6  3. Bb5 a6  4. Ba4 Bc5  5. 0-0 Nf6  6. d3 b5  7. Bb3 0-0  8. c3 h6
9. Qe2 d6  10. Be3 Bxe3  11. Fxe3 Ne7  12. Nbd2 Ng6  13. Rad1 Qe7  14. h3 Be6  15. Qf2 Bxb3
16. axb3 c5  17. Nh4 Nh7  18. Nf5 Qe6  19. c4 Ne7  20. g4 Kh8  21. Qh4 Ng6  22. Qg3 Ne7
23. Nb1 Rab8  24. Rf2 b4  25. Nd2 Ra8  26. Ra1 Ra7  27. Nf3 Nxf5  28. exf5 Qe7  29. e4 a5
30. h4 Qd7  31. Ra4 Rg8  32. g5 g6  33. f6 h5  34. Ne1 Nf8  35. Nc2 Ne6  36. Qh3 Rd8
37. Rf3   draw agreed   ½-½

 

Alan Robertson started the new year by discarding his favoured Pirc defence and went instead for the Sicilian Najdorf against Alan Ormsby.  The latter responded with the Fischer attack, castling long and advancing his king side pawns.  An injudicious pawn capture by Robertson left Ormsby with an open file to his opponent's king which quickly resulted in a mating attack.

White: Alan Ormsby v Black: Alan Robertson     
1. e4 c5  2. Nf3 d6  3. d4 cxd4  4. Nxd4 Nf6  5. Nc3 a6  6. Bc4 e6  7. Bb3 Nc6  8. Be3 Be7
9. Qe2 Qc7  10. f4 b5  11. 0-0-0 Bb7  12. f5 Nxd4  13. Bxd4 e5(a)  14. Bf2 0-0  15. Kb1 Rac8
16. g4 b4  17. Nd5 Bxd5  18. Bxd5 Nxg4  19. Rhg1 h5(b)  20. h3 Nf6?  21. Bb3 Qb7
22. Bh4 Qb5?  23. Qg2(c) Ng4  24. Bxe7 Rfe8  25. hxg4 Rxe7  26. gxa5       1-0
(a)  Better was b4                 
(b)  Better 19....Nxf2  20. Qxf2 Bf6  White has full compensation for the pawn by applying strong
      pressure down the g file, but maybe black can hold due to the bishop on f6.
(c)  and white now has a mating attack

 

The Dutch defence of John Costello to Frank Maher's English opening left John encumbered with double isolated pawns, a grave weakness in an ending.  However, Frank lost a pawn due to a tactical oversight and his game then deteriorated rapidly so that he had to concede without getting to an endgame.

White: Frank Maher v Black: John Costello     
1. c4 e5  2. g3 f5!?  3. Bg2 Nf6  4. Nc3 Nc6  5. a3 a5  6. d3 h6  7. f4 d6  8. Bxc6+!? bxc6
9. fxe5 dxe5  10. e3?! Be6  11. b3 Bc5  12. Nge2 0-0  13. d4 exd4  14. exd4 Be7  15. Nf4 Bf7
16. 0-0 Re8  17. Be3?! Bxa3  18. Qf3?(a) Bb2  19. Nce2 Bxa1  20. Rxa1 Ng4  21. Bd2 g5
22. h3 gxf4  23. hxg4 Rxe2  24. Qxe2 Qxd4+ and whites rook is lost     1-0
(a) 18. Rxa3 Rxe3  19. Qd2 Re8 was better

TROMPOWSKI

 

 

____________________________________________________________________

 

 MANX  CHAMPIONSHIPS 2000/2001 ARCHIVES

 

____________________________________________________________________